Syvak’s Museum of Heresies

An eclectic integral blog of my personal studies

Does Illness Mean Anything?

Posted by Jamil Syvak on May 25, 2008

I’ve recently started reading this book since my wife has just been diagnosed with breast cancer. (On our fifteenth year anniversary of all days!) The book was just kind of waiting for me on my bookshelf. Its been helping a lot.

In Grace and Grit: Spirituality and Healing in the Life of Treya Killam Wilber (Shambala Publications, 2000), philosopher Ken Wilber discusses the meaning that various cultural and healing traditions give to illness.

1. Christian: The fundamentalist message: Illness is basically a punishment from God for some sort of sin. The worse the illness, the more unspeakable the sin.

2. New Age: Illness is a lesson. You are giving yourself this disease because there is something important you have to learn from it in order to continue your spiritual growth and evolution. Mind alone causes illness and mind alone can cure it. A yuppified postmodern version of Christian Science.

3. Medical: Illness is fundamentally a biophysical disorder, caused by biophysical factors (from viruses to trauma to genetic predisposition to environmental triggering agents). You needn’t worry about psychological or spiritual treatments for most illnesses, because such alternative treatments are usually ineffectual and may actually prevent you from getting the proper medical attention.

4. Karma: Illness is the result of negative karma; that is, some nonvirtuous past actions are now coming to fruition in the form of a disease. The disease is “bad” in the sense that it represents past nonvirtue; but it is “good” in the sense that the disease process itself represents the burning up and the purifying of the past misdeed; it’s a purgation, a cleansing.

5. Psychological: As Woody Allen put it, “1 don’t get angry; I grow tumors instead.” The idea is that, at least in pop psychology, repressed emotions cause illness. The extreme form: Illness as death wish.

6. Gnostic: Illness is an illusion. The entire manifest universe is a dream, a shadow, and one is free of illness only when one is free from illusory manifestation altogether, only when one awakens from the dream and discovers instead the One reality beyond the manifest universe. Spirit is the only reality, and in Spirit there is no illness. An extreme and somewhat off-centered version of mysticism.

7. Existential: Illness itself is without meaning. Accordingly it can take any meaning I choose to give it, and I am solely response for these choices. Men and women are finite and mortal, and the authentic response is to accept illness as part of one’s Finitude even while imbuing it with personal meaning.

8. Holistic: Illness is a product of physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual factors, none of which can be isolated from the others, none of which can be ignored. Treatment must involve all of these dimensions {although in practice this often translates into an eschewal of orthodox treatments, even when they might help.

9. Magical: Illness is retribution. “I deserve this because I wished So-and-so would die.” Or, “I better not excel too much, something bad will happen to me.” Or, “If too many good things happen to me, something bad has to happen.” And so on.

10. Buddhist: Illness is an inescapable part of the manifest world; asking why there is illness is like asking why there is air. Birth, old age, sickness, and death – these are the marks of this world, all of whose phenomena are characterized by impermanence, suffering, and selflessness. Only in enlightenment, in the pure awareness of nirvana, is illness finally transcended, because then the entire phenomenal world is transcended as well.

11. Scientific: Whatever the illness is, it has a specific cause or cluster of causes. Some of these causes are determined, others are simply random or due to pure chance. Either way, there is no “meaning” to illness, there is only chance or necessity.


2 Responses to “Does Illness Mean Anything?”

  1. Greetings of Peace dear friend on the path.

    glad to see my posts as RSS in your blog.

    thank you for putting out the points from Ken’s great book. good wisdom to share for us all.

    blessings upon blessings.

  2. Greetings of peace my friend.

    Wilber’s book is definitely a fascinating read and quite illuminating. It is one of those rare gems.

    BTW, I have been meaning to post a comment on your blog. Your blog is, obviously, a daily read of mine and one of the best blogs I have seen. Keep the good work up.

    Blessings to you.

    Salaam alaykum,

    Jamil Syvak

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: